Tamil Information Centre
User Name:   
  Remember Me  
Sign up  |  Forget password
    Contact us
Book Review: The Seasons o f Trouble
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Sunday)


By Aditya Sinha

Two books that are reportage from the Sri Lankan civil war—the fighting ended in May 2009—were published this year. Samanth Subramanian’s This Divided Island, published four months ago, took a macro view of the war’s end and its aftermath; in his own words, “picked at a loose tile and found a stash of corpses buried underneath”. It meditated on the tug-of-war over memory between the state and the individual, and took both the Sri Lankan army as well as the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) to task.

Rohini Mohan’s The Seasons Of Trouble: Life Amid The Ruins Of Sri Lanka’s Civil War, takes a micro view of the war’s end by, metaphorically speaking, selecting a couple of the corpses from under that loose tile and telling their stories, and the intimate stories-within-those-stories. It depicts the past as that which cannot be escaped, and memory as a tool for survival. It has no time for judgement because its protagonists are too busy running for their lives, often literally.

Rohini Mohan’s book is, not surprisingly, intense and powerful, engrossing and engaging, and she has a couple of cool narrative tricks up her sleeve. Like the other book, The Seasons Of Trouble is among the best of 2014—a rare occurrence for two non-fiction books on the same subject. And seeing the dearth of satisfying reportage from separatist conflicts in the recent past—despite the many conflict zones in and around our neighbourhood—it is a must-read. photo The Seasons Of Trouble—Life Amid The Ruins Of Sri Lanka’s Civil War: Harper Collins, 353 pages, Rs499

Through two stories, The Seasons Of Trouble speaks of three lives: of Mugil, a former teenage member of the LTTE, who in the final stages of the war is moving her two sons, her parents, her sister’s family, and home and hearth, from one battlefield to another, finally ending up at a detention camp. And of Sarva, a seaman who grew up on a tea plantation in central Lanka and who is about to embark on a European adventure when he is suddenly abducted and whisked off to a secret detention centre because the Sri Lankan authorities believe he is LTTE; and of Sarva’s mother, given the pseudonym Indra, who spends a lot of money and time—once she discovers her son’s whereabouts—on first his release, then his escape, and then his illegal emigration.

Mugil’s story opens in September 2008 with her witnessing the rape/murder of five teenaged LTTE girls by Lankan soldiers near Kilinochchi, and her furtive escape to her home in Puthukudiyirippu, located in the Vanni, the heart of the Tamil homeland in northern Lanka. Her family had moved there from Point Pedro (aka Paruthithurai), the Lankan tip where the Bay of Bengal and Arabian Sea meet, and that is where—once the war is over and she’s spent 20 months at the Manik Farm detention camp—she will be relocated to by the army, which has grabbed much of the farmland in the Vanni, turning it into a cantonment and a Sinhalese war memorial. Mugil’s husband Divyan, whom she met in the LTTE and who is still a part of the rebel force, is away. Over eight months, she and her family will walk to the coast and spend 6 hours walking through the Nandikadal Lagoon on the way to Putumalan, only to end up in Manik Farm’s Zone 2, with 76,000 other refugees.

The LTTE had given Mugil, when she was 13, autonomy and individuality: “...Mugil wished her mother would not speak to her as if she was still a child. ‘If you mean plait my hair, wear flowers and bangles and prettily wait for a husband, you should know better,’ she replied.”

She has to practise restraint to save herself and her family, but it isn’t easy: “If they deserted the LTTE, they could be spotted anywhere. The bob had become a sign of imprisonment, rather than personal freedom.”

The army bombs the LTTE’s so-called safe zones and when Mugil visits Valipunam, you get a sense of the continuum of suffering: “The shelling was past, but the burning present.” Her father remarks, perceptively: “What do you do when you can’t deal with locusts? You burn the field. That’s what they’re doing—eradicating as many Tamils as possible.” So they walk, and one of the book’s most heart-rending moments describes a woman carrying two children across the Nandikadal Lagoon: “The woman lost her footing and crashed into the water, surfacing with only one of her sons. She screamed, whipped her head around, begged people to go under and look for her baby. Some did, but it didn’t help. The wailing woman had to give up and cross to save her other child.”

The other narrative details, in episodes, Sarva’s two-year detention (incidentally, Sri Lanka has the world’s second highest rate of illegal detention after Iraq). Sarva’s body and spirit are repeatedly assaulted—by interrogators, then by fellow prisoners, and then by being on the run while he awaits a chance to emigrate. You get glimpses of the man with joie de vivre through his sense of humour, his voluble talk, his love for cooking. His encounters with women after two years of detention are not surprising: “When Shirleen came back to meet him a few days later, another beautiful woman accompanied her. He was all in a tizzy. Were all social workers stunning, or was Randy playing a prank on him?”

If he has a luckier fate than others, it is because of his unrelenting mother. Indra is in fact so determined to find her disappeared son that in another context, when she returns to her home in Nuwara Eliya, a Vanni newspaper runs a story headlined: “‘Pillaiyai thedi vantha thaaiyai kaanavillai!’ The mother searching for her son is missing!” So focused is Indra that her husband is invisible in the narrative and her children resentful of their brother, despite the gravity of his situation. Yet it is this focus which ensures that fate is kind to Sarva who, after months of being stranded by unscrupulous traffickers in Bolivia en route to the US, finally lands in the UK, where he gets asylum.

Unlike Subramanian’s book, which has to be detached in its reportage in order to take in the big picture, Mohan’s book necessarily requires a fictive pace and immersion. She does it effortlessly so that the stories she tells, and the stories within them, contain cliff-hangers, twists and resolutions. Sarva has a happy ending so long as he never returns to his homeland; Mugil’s narrative ends with a sinister foreshadowing of further violence in the country, and with the detention of a major character whose ordeal will no doubt be similar to Sarva’s.

Isaiah Berlin said there were two ways of doing philosophy—that of the fox and the hedgehog. The fox jumps from point to point so many times it covers a big picture, while the hedgehog digs so deep in one place that it hits a fundamental truth. Rohini Mohan’s book digs so deep that it touches your heart—and unsettles it.



Share on Facebook

 Latest 25 News/ பிந்திய 25 செய்திகள்:
Tamil Information Centre (TIC) expresses grief over brutal, cowardly attacks on churches and other places in Sri Lanka
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Monday)
அனுபவம் மிக்க சிரேஸ்ட தொகுப்பாளர் N.T Jegan அவர்களோடு info4tamils இணைய வழி தொலைக்காட்சியினூடக கண்காட்சி பற்றிய கலந்துரையாடல்
பிரசுரிக்கபட்ட திகதி: 08/02/2015 (வியாழக்கிழமை)
இலங்கைத் தமிழர்கள்: காலவரையறையற்றதொரு பாரம்பரியம் என்ற கண்காட்சிதொடர்பான தமிழ் தகவல் நடுவத்தின் (TIC) உத்தியோகபூர்வ அறிக்கை
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Thursday)
கண்ணீர் அஞ்சலி
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Thursday)
Report reveals bone samples belong to 1499-1719 AD era
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Monday)
Northern Province’s Economic Development Framework
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Monday)
OMP welcomes inclusion of its interim relief proposals in budget
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Monday)
Raghavan to take public concerns to UNHrc
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Saturday)
Jaffna to get Olympic-standard aquatic complex
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Saturday)
Treat women and girls with respect - EDITORIAL
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Saturday)
Vandalizing archaeological sites - Cabinet approves upping fines, jail terms
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Saturday)
Right time to abolish executive presidency - JVP
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Saturday)
International Court Of Justice & The ‘Ceylon Tamils’
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Saturday)
British Tamil Students Build War-Torn Mullaitivu's First Media Centre
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Friday)
Joint Press Release: Sri Lanka sends war crimes denier to Geneva as part of official delegation.
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Thursday)
Karannagoda drags Gota into mass murder case
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Monday)
Tamils’ Hopes Fading: Every Village Is Sinhalese? Rāghavan Sacked?
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Sunday)
106 Tamil Diaspora Groups Jointly Urge UNHRC Not to Give any more Additional Time to Sri Lanka - Urge to Refer to ICC
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Sunday)
Ten Years After A War Without Witnesses: Global Tamil Forum Calls To Ensure Sri Lanka Firmly Remains On The UNHRC Agenda
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Sunday)
Human Rights Council 40: UK Statement for the Interactive Dialogue with the Special Rapporteur on the Protection of Human Rights while Countering Terrorism
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Saturday)
Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe, while speaking at the Kilinochchi District development review meeting, blamed the Northern Provincial Council authorities, saying that they have almost become inactive towards the problems faced by the people in North.
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Friday)
Ranil blasts Northern Provincial Council
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Friday)
Approval for TRC mechanism Navi Pillay blasts Govt
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Thursday)
A New ‘Washington Consensus’ ‘Indo–Pacific’ and India’s Emerging Role
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Thursday)
US resumes Millennium Challenge aid to Sri Lanka
Published Date: 08/02/2015 (Thursday)
Support our work to bring rights to life in any way big or small

Donate using PayPal

Select dates to view
past and future events
<<<Jul - 2019>>>
 Stand up for Rights and Justice
Grant 18 year old Saudi Woman Rahaf asylum in the UK
Take Action
Call to Ban Monsanto’s pesticide
Trump’s child hostages
Set Noura Free -- sign now!
Latest Publication
Proto Sumero Dravidian: The Common Origin of Sumerian and Dravidian Languages Conference Report:

Proto Sumero Dravidian: The Common Origin of Sumerian and Dravidian Languages


About us
Site Help
Getting in touch
Facebook Youtube twitter
Sitemap  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms and Conditions
Copyright © 2019 ticonline.org, All rights reserved.