Tamil Information Centre
User Name:   
Password:   
  Remember Me  
Sign up  |  Forget password
Home   
Search
    Contact us
Longer wait for SC decision
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Tuesday)
  • Three-member bench hears cases in a packed courthouse 
  • 11 petitions filed against President’s decision to dissolve Parliament declaring the move “unconstitutional and illegal”
  • AG’s request for more time refused 
  • AG to file his arguments today morning 

Civil society members, activists, and politicians alike sought the intervention of the Supreme Court as their last refuge yesterday, filing 11 fundamental rights petitions claiming President Maithripala Sirisena’s decision to dissolve Parliament was unconstitutional. 

In an unprecedented move, one of the three members of the Election Commission, Dr. Ratnajeevan Hoole, was also among those who petitioned the three-member bench, claiming the move by Sirisena to dissolve Parliament was ex facie illegal, stating that he was duty bound to ensure the Constitution was honoured.

As the country’s political crisis entered yet another new phase, with Sirisena’s sudden move to dissolve Parliament days before his new Prime Minister was to show majority in the House, activists and politicians flocked to the Supreme Court as their last resort. The three-member bench, comprising of Chief Justice Nalin Perera and Justices Prasanna Jayawardane and Priyantha Jayawardane, listened to arguments listed out by petitioners in a courtroom packed to its capacity with lawyers, politicians, and journalists. 

The sense of gravity was almost tangible when the Court decided to hear the cases filed just yesterday morning, taking into consideration the urgency of the matter, despite the Attorney General (AG) claiming that proper notice should be given to the Elections Commission. It was pointed out to the Court that one of the three members of the Elections Commission (EC), Dr. Hoole, was himself a petitioner in the matter, therefore the concern on notice was not valid. 

AG Jayantha Jayasuriya’s request for more time until at least Wednesday was denied by the Bench, which directed him to submit his argument today at 10 am. 

EC Member Dr Hoole, in his petition, sought to clarify the legality of dissolving the Parliament by the President. Dr. Hoole’s Attorney-at-Law Hijaz Hisbullah told Court that his client was “deeply conscious” of the need to maintain a degree of neutrality, due to the position he holds as a member of the Election Commission, but cited Justice Mark Fernando’s 1999 Supreme Court ruling in the Karunatillake Vs. Dayananda Dissanayake case, filed against the indefinite postponement of elections for five provincial councils in August 1998, which held that the Elections Commission should have obtained a judicial order in order to implement election laws. 

Presenting his argument, Hisbullah noted that the proclamation that dissolves Parliament is ex facie illegal, as “there is only one article in the entire Constitution that allows for dissolution of Parliament by proclamation, and that is Article 70 (1).” The counsel noted that the President had avoided complying with that article when he dissolved Parliament.

The lawyer for the EC member said they were arguing “elementary matters of constitutional law”. “If Article 33 (2) can stand alone, when the President is being impeached, for violating the constitution or because he is mentally unfit  - that he may still proceed to dissolve Parliament under 33 (2)?” Hisbullah asked. He also told the Court that honouring the election result was also as important as holding elections and allowing people to exercise their franchise. “At an election all people gather to express an opinion. If we allow the President to dissolve Parliament at any time, it says that the opinion of the President trumps all other opinions. There is one word for that, my lords – dictatorship.”

The counsel for the EC member also noted the urgency of granting interim relief to stay the election, saying the poll would be held at a great cost to the State. “The machinery has already started moving, and preliminary work to hold elections has begun,” he warned, saying the poll should be stayed until the Court concluded determining the matter.

The majority of the counsel presenting before the bench found fault with the President’s use of Article 33 (2), which has been done independent of Article 70 (1), which sets limits on his powers listed in the earlier Article 33 (2). 

The proclamation by the President refers to Article 33 (2) of the Constitution, which gives him general powers to ‘summon, prorogue and dissolve Parliament’, but does not refer to the special provisions set out in the Constitution which set limits on his powers to do so.

Lawyers arguing noted that the provision in Article 33 (2) should be read with the provisions in Article 70, which sets out the framework within which the President’s powers to summon, prorogue and dissolve Parliament can be exercised.

“Article 33 says the President shall hold the Seal of the Republic – that doesn’t mean he can go and place the Seal anywhere he likes. There are special provisions listed in the Constitution setting out the instances in which the Seal may be used. A similar law of interpretation applies to the President’s power to dissolve Parliament,” K. Kanag-Iswaran PC argued for his petitioner, Opposition Leader R. Sampanthan.

M.A. Sumanthiran PC, counsel for petitioner Champika Fernando, also noted that if 70(1) is ignored in this manner, after a new Parliament sits - on January 17, according to the Gazette notification – then, on the very next day, i.e., January 18, Parliament could be dissolved. “What if the President doesn’t like the face of the next Prime Minister or something else? Can that be permitted?”

Attorney General Jayantha Jayasuriya, who was cited in the petitions as representing the President, whose actions were being challenged in all the cases filed yesterday, appealed for more time – at least until Wednesday – to make submissions, but was denied. 

 

Source: Daily FT

Share on Facebook


 Latest 25 News/ பிந்திய 25 செய்திகள்:
Skeletons of 21 children found in mass grave in Sri Lanka with 'signs of torture' So far 276 skeletons have been exhumed from ‘largest mass grave ever explored on island’
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Saturday)
K.S. Sivakumaran discusses Lankan Tamil culture
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Friday)
Sri Lanka\'s UNF expects Wickremesinghe re-appointment, JVP wants \'coup\' leaders punished
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Friday)
‘Citizens’ as suckers
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Thursday)
Wheelchair Expedition 'Perseverance' Finished in Point Pedro Challenging 'Challenges in Life'
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Thursday)
UNP: Purported pact with TNA, forged by SLPP
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Thursday)
Diasporas as a force in foreign affairs: the case of Tamils in Britain and Canada
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Thursday)
Life in 'slavery' or as a refugee? Cuban doctors' stark choice in Brazil
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Thursday)
US lawmaker seeks an end to Chinese debt trap
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Thursday)
US envoy called upon to exercise diligence - Cabraal
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Wednesday)
Lanka’s high ageing population, a cause for concern - WHO
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Wednesday)
Estate workers protest against Thondaman
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Wednesday)
TNA says its support was conditional
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Wednesday)
Teach everyone’s history for reconciliation
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Wednesday)
First comprehensive survey of Sri Lankan art organized by a U.S. museum opens in Los Angeles
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Wednesday)
New study estimates 500 Tamils disappeared in Army custody in Sri Lanka after surrendering at the end of the war in 2009.
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Wednesday)
Ancient grape seeds may link Sri Lankan trading port to Roman world
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Wednesday)
Mannar mass grave: Skeletal remains of 21 children unearthed
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Wednesday)
HR should be part of daily life – HRCSL Chair
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Wednesday)
The new arms race: American businesses vs. China’s government money How we outsourced foreign aid to private companies
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Tuesday)
PM, ministers not removed; only functions suspended: GL
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Tuesday)
President to appoint new govt. if P’ment undissolved: SLFP
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Tuesday)
Sri Lanka needs its own leaders
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Tuesday)
Former DIG Nalaka de Silva further remanded
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Tuesday)
Investigate President’s claims on bribing MPs-TISL
Published Date: 13/11/2018 (Tuesday)
Donate
Support our work to bring rights to life in any way big or small
 Amount:

Donate using PayPal

Select dates to view
past and future events
<<<Dec - 2018>>>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
      1
2345678
9
10
1112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031     
 Stand up for Rights and Justice
Call to Ban Monsanto’s pesticide
Read more...
Take Action
Trump’s child hostages
Set Noura Free -- sign now!
Tamil men accuse continuing torture in Sri Lanka Take a stand against torture and urge UN Human Rights commission for human rights to investigate
Latest Publication
Proto Sumero Dravidian: The Common Origin of Sumerian and Dravidian Languages Conference Report:

Proto Sumero Dravidian: The Common Origin of Sumerian and Dravidian Languages

Read more...

Thiruvalluvar
About us
Site Help
Getting in touch
Other
Facebook Youtube twitter
Sitemap  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms and Conditions
Copyright © 2018 ticonline.org, All rights reserved.